The Buy and Hold Fairy

Fairy with a gift

I think that everyone who has ever bought a stock has dreamed of buying one for a few dollars per share and selling it down the road for many dollars per share.  The good old buy it, hold it and sell it at the top strategy.  In spite of a 40% pounding last year and a negative return over the last 10 years the dream is still alive. The tooth fairy bit the dust when most were 5 or 6 years old, but the Buy and Hold fairy must have nine lives or something.

The following is a headline from this weekend’s Wall Street Journal:  Top Fund Manager Sees Decade Ruined, Hodges ‘Very Much Embarrassed,’ Regroups after Nearly 50% drop in 2008.  The article goes on to say, “A $10,000 investment in Hodges Fund made 10 years ago would be worth around $9,015 today, compared with $7,720 if it was invested in the S&P 500 index.”  At least he outperformed the market. I didn’t read the rest of the article, because it wasn’t worth my time.  I betcha it didn’t mention the millions of dollars he collected in fees over the past ten years for that dismal performance.  Embarrassed give me a break.

In my opinion, to make a buck in the market you must first take charge of your own finances.  At least if you lose money, you won’t be shelling out thousands of dollars in fees to the “pros” for similar results.  Secondly, you must say good-bye to the Buy and Hold fairy.  She was comforting as a kid, but now it is time to move on.

Buy and Sell should be the new mantra.  Learn how to employ entry and exit techniques.  Become more of a trader than an investor.  If trading sounds too much like work, focus on saving and leave the market to others.

Filed Under: Investing

Tags:

About the Author:

  • The "Buy and Hold Fairy" - I like it Michael!

    I think the Buy and Hold Fairy was invented by the Mutual Fund industry who last year had $8.53 trillion in equities under management. Perpetuating the Myth of Buy and Hold is worth a lot of money to them in fees.

    What scares me is that those selling the Buy and Hold approach lead people to believe that average annual returns of 8+% can be expected over the long term. This is such a half truth it is a lie. Market history reveals that success through Buy and Hold occurs only when you are lucky enough to hold during a prolonged period when the market does well. There have been three periods longer than 57 years when the US market has achieved no real growth at all after inflation.

    The Buy and Hold investor thinks that they can’t lose over the long term but not many realize that the long term on the US market historically has been as long as 130 years! However Buy and Hold is still the best option for most people and far better than not investing at all but for the diligent investor there are far better options.

    See how the numbers stack up here – http://etfhq.com/blog/2010/02/19/buy-and-hold/
blog comments powered by Disqus
  • Recent Comments